The Return of the Soldier – Rebecca West

Rebecca West’s The Return of the Soldier was written during the first world war. Perhaps understandably it is not especially cheerful but it is an astute slice of life story. It offers what I thought was a wonderful insight into human behaviour and the effects of war.

The story is narrated by Jenny who shares a home with her cousin Chris and his wife Kitty. It is obvious from the beginning that Jenny is devoted to her cousin. Her purpose in life seems to be to work alongside Kitty to make his life as comfortable and happy as possible. This is a job they both take seriously, the furnishings in the house, even the layout of the garden designed to be comforting and peaceful.

Chris returns early from the war, shellshocked, the past 15 years of his life and the turmoil in the world erased from his memory. He doesn’t remember his wife at all and only remembers his cousin as a young playmate, not the woman she now is. This is something that bothers Jenny. He believes himself to still be in love with Margaret, his girlfriend from that period who is now married herself.

Margaret is central to the story. Kitty and Jenny consider her to be poor, unattractive and badly groomed, to the extent that they are embarrassed for her and to be around her. They don’t consider her a threat at all but soon realise that Chris in his regressed state is besotted with her. She comes to their house to see Chris, to aid in his recovery. Initially hostile, Jenny warms to her, begins to appreciate her genuine and simple character, feels nourished by her company. We don’t learn much about Kitty, she is portrayed as being beautiful and shallow, clothed in silks and struggling to believe that her husband could prefer this undesirable woman over her.

The outer beauty of Kitty contrasted against the inner beauty of Margaret.

The women’s actions will be crucial to the outcome. Especially those of Margaret. Does she follow her heart and in doing so protect her former love – as long as he is “ill”, Chris will be kept away from the front. Or does she do the right thing, honour their respective marriages and help him to recover is memory.

This was one of Rebecca West’s earlier novels, written when she was 24. It is short and I didn’t get to engage with the characters but it introduced all sorts of issues begging to be explored further. Rebecca West sounded like a fascinating woman and I’m looking forward to learning more about her. I would also like to read her non fiction/travel memoir, Black Lamb and Grey Falcon: A Journey through Yugoslavia which was written later in her life.

Read for the Decades 2010, Global reading and Support your local library challenges

1918, 112 pages


10 responses to “The Return of the Soldier – Rebecca West

  1. Wow, this sounds really good. I’ve never heard of this book or this author, so I’m really glad you posted this. I’ll definitely keep it in mind.

  2. Anna – That’s great, I hope you get to read it at some stage. I haven’t read many books from the early 20th century and it really was well done. Something to keep in mind for future War through the generations challenges maybe?!

  3. We’ll do WWI at some point, I’m sure!

  4. Rebecca West is one of those authors I have never got round to reading. She’s never on the bookshop shelves any more, and there aren’t any of her books in my library. Frustrating…

    • Lisa – That is frustrating and makes me think of Ann Bridge’s Illyrian Spring which after reading a review I was dying to read but can’t find. It seems that knowing an author is hard to find makes me want to read them even more!

  5. I have this on my shelves but I didn’t get on very well with West’s The Fountain Overflows.

    • Claire – With so many books to read, it’s hard to find time for an author that hasn’t previously impressed isn’t it? One thing I would say is that this isn’t a book that really involved me as the reader, I enjoyed it more as a fly on the wall type read.

  6. Oooh, this sounded so good I just bought it for Kindle. Thanks!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s