Greenbanks – Dorothy Whipple

Greenbanks was one of two books I was given by Santa for Christmas. My Santa very thoughtfully made his way into Persephone books for the first time and picked the exact book I would have chosen myself as well as No Surrender by Constance Maud. Great choices – so I feel very lucky.

Reading Dorothy Whipple is like revisiting a comfortable and cherished friend. The ordinariness of her characters and their lives makes it so easy to relate to and to step into their shoes. You wouldn’t expect it to be escapist reading but in a way it is – somehow she manages to include her reader in the story, it’s like being in the same room as the action is taking place. Whipple’s insight into human emotions and family dynamics is spot on, I haven’t yet read a book of hers and not felt accutely what at least one of her characters was feeling.

Greenbanks is the name of a house or more accurately a home in . Three generations live or have lived there – Louisa, her brood of children and their children – in particular Rachel, a 6 year old when the story begins in the years approaching the First World War – nearly coming of age as it finishes. Rachel is Louisa’s favourite grandchild and these two are the heart of the story. Their goodness balances out the weaknesses in the other characters. The story is about the people who inhabit the house – Greenbanks being the hub where at one time or another, everyone returns to.

Each of Whipple’s stories seems to have a man who is a villian of sorts, not so much in the criminal way but in the way he treats people, especially women. In Greenbanks this task is enthusiastically tackled by Ambrose, husband to Louisa’s daughter Letty and father of Rachel. Ambrose is a fantastic character, so infuriating – controlling and thoughtless, yet vulnerable too.

Through her male characters and sometimes through less than wonderful female characters, Dorothy Whipple highlights the plight of women in a subtle way but one which leaves no doubt as to how difficult it could be in the first decades of the 20th century to be a woman. There is a scene in Greenbanks where Ambrose tries to interfere with his daughter going to universtiy – I was outraged and that was just reading about it – imagine actually living it!

But – and this is one of the loveliest things about Whipple’s characters, she doesn’t judge and no matter how difficult, there will always be people in her stories who shine, who find a way to flourish regardless – that’s what makes her reads so satisfying I think and also important. They are more than just a pleasant read about domestic life. They also reflect the constant changes and progression of their times. Life is not the same before and after the war.

Greenbanks is a slow burner – I wondered early on if this was going to be the first Dorothy Whipple that I didn’t love. I should have had more faith, she hasn’t let me down yet. The story gathers momentum and gets better by the page towards the end.

392 pages, 1932 (republished 2011)


6 responses to “Greenbanks – Dorothy Whipple

  1. I haven’t read her yet but am very much looking forwad to reading her this year. It’s interesting that you say it’s escapist depsite the fact that people and events are sort of ordinary but then there are the people that shine, as you write, and we all need some of those in our lives. That sounds lovely.

  2. Caroline – Oh I really hope you like her, I’ll look out for your thoughts. You will have a wonderful collection of books to read if you do. I’ve read a few reviews of Greenbanks with people thinking it is their favourite. Mine is still Someone at a Distance.

    And you are right – we all need people that shine in our lives.

  3. I love your reviews. They are gentle, well thought out, perceptive, and incite me to read what you’ve written about as soon as possible. I’ve not read anything by Dorothy Whipple yet, but I received a copy of Greenbanks as well. I guess I’m waiting for a small, still moment to read it.

  4. Bellezza – you are very kind thank you. Your thoughtful comments are so appreciated. How lovely that you have a copy of Greenbanks. Yes, do pick a quiet time to curl up and savour. I can’t wait to see if you like her writing. I have a feeling that you will and hope that you do.

  5. What a wonderful Santa! For me this book was escapist for the simple reson that it had me completely caught up.

  6. FleurFisher – yes, exactly! I was also swept away and that is a great reason to read a book as far as I can tell 0:)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s